Siwash vs treble hook for jointed minnows trolling?

Question

FishGPT · Accepted Answer

When it comes to trolling with **jointed minnows**, the choice between **siwash hooks** and **treble hooks** can significantly impact your fishing success. Let's break down the pros and cons of each to help you make an informed decision.

### **Treble Hooks**

**Pros:**
- **Higher Hook-Up Rate:** Treble hooks have three points, increasing the chances of a successful hook-up when a fish strikes.
- **Better for Aggressive Fish:** Ideal for species that strike hard and fast, ensuring they get hooked even with a quick bite.

**Cons:**
- **More Snags:** Treble hooks are more likely to get caught on underwater structures, weeds, and even your own gear.
- **Harder on Fish:** If you're practicing catch and release, treble hooks can cause more damage to the fish, making it harder for them to survive post-release.

### **Siwash Hooks**

**Pros:**
- **Less Damage to Fish:** Siwash hooks are single hooks, making them less damaging and easier to remove, which is great for catch and release.
- **Fewer Snags:** With only one point, siwash hooks are less likely to get snagged, making your trolling experience smoother.

**Cons:**
- **Lower Hook-Up Rate:** With only one point, the chances of a successful hook-up can be lower compared to treble hooks.
- **Not Ideal for All Species:** Some fish species may not get hooked as effectively with a single hook, especially if they are known for quick, aggressive strikes.

### **Conclusion**

If you're targeting aggressive fish and don't mind dealing with a few snags, **treble hooks** might be your best bet. However, if you're practicing catch and release or fishing in snag-prone areas, **siwash hooks** could be the way to go. Either way, both hooks have their place in a well-rounded tackle box. Happy trolling! 🎣

Swimbait Questions

More Questions

The 2.2\" Epic Whipwad

If you had $36 on a gift card for entry-level fly fishing gear, how would you spend it?

I have rod SHINJU ROD – COBRA KING #SCK 802 MHS, rig setup to fishing inshore target medium size fish

How can I catch bass in Rockingham, NC?

What should I expect on a three-day fly fishing float trip on the Green River?

No, is there spillways and dams I can fish at near Watertown SD

I want to buy a Shimano Calcutta for my dobbins 7ft 1 mod fast rod which one should I get

Which fish can we catch spinning from the beach mid-October on Spiaggia Plaja, Sicily?

Siwash vs treble hook for jointed minnows trolling?

Related Videos

Product Recommendations

Hot Spot A5-156R Apex Trolling Lure 4.5", 4/0 Siwash Hook, Mother of

Owner Stinger Siwash Hook, Black, 4/0 (5171-141)

Gamakatsu 10013 Siwash Loose Hook (6 Pack), Size 3/0, Nickel

Mustad Ultra Point 2X Fine Wire Kirbed Point Big Gun Open Eye Siwash Hook (Pack of 6), Black Nickel, Size 2/0

Mustad Salmon Siwash, 3X Strong, Hollow Point, Open Ring 4/0

Mustad Big Gun Open Eye Siwash, 1X Fine, Wide Gap, Kirbed 2/0, Black/Nickel

Community

Swimbait Questions

The 2.2\" Epic Whipwad

What are the best high end lightweight glidebait and swimbait reels to match with a 2-4 oz shimano outlier dedicated swimbait rod

What fishing lures to use for fishing barracuda

que señuelos utilizar para pescar bicudas o barracudas

Siwash vs treble hook for jointed minnows trolling?

Related Videos

Product Recommendations

Hot Spot A5-156R Apex Trolling Lure 4.5", 4/0 Siwash Hook, Mother of

Owner Stinger Siwash Hook, Black, 4/0 (5171-141)

Gamakatsu 10013 Siwash Loose Hook (6 Pack), Size 3/0, Nickel

Mustad Ultra Point 2X Fine Wire Kirbed Point Big Gun Open Eye Siwash Hook (Pack of 6), Black Nickel, Size 2/0

Mustad Salmon Siwash, 3X Strong, Hollow Point, Open Ring 4/0

Mustad Big Gun Open Eye Siwash, 1X Fine, Wide Gap, Kirbed 2/0, Black/Nickel

Community

The 2.2\" Epic Whipwad

If you had $36 on a gift card for entry-level fly fishing gear, how would you spend it?

I have rod SHINJU ROD – COBRA KING #SCK 802 MHS, rig setup to fishing inshore target medium size fish

How can I catch bass in Rockingham, NC?

What should I expect on a three-day fly fishing float trip on the Green River?

No, is there spillways and dams I can fish at near Watertown SD

I want to buy a Shimano Calcutta for my dobbins 7ft 1 mod fast rod which one should I get

Which fish can we catch spinning from the beach mid-October on Spiaggia Plaja, Sicily?

The 2.2\" Epic Whipwad

What are the best high end lightweight glidebait and swimbait reels to match with a 2-4 oz shimano outlier dedicated swimbait rod

What fishing lures to use for fishing barracuda

que señuelos utilizar para pescar bicudas o barracudas