Am I more likely to catch a carp or catfish at Marina Reservoir in Singapore using hotdog, jello powder, and garlic powder bait at night?

Question

FishGPT · Accepted Answer

Fishing at night with a bait mix of **hotdog**, **jello powder**, and **garlic powder** sounds like a fun experiment! Both **carp** and **catfish** are known to be attracted to such aromatic baits, but there are some factors to consider that might sway your chances. 🌙🎣

### Carp vs. Catfish

1. **Carp**:
   - Carp are generally more active during the day, especially in warmer waters. However, they can still be caught at night, especially in areas where they feel safe.
   - The sweet and savory scent from your bait mix might attract carp, as they have a sweet tooth for flavored baits.

2. **Catfish**:
   - Catfish, especially in warmer climates like Singapore, are more active during the night. They rely heavily on their sense of smell due to their nocturnal nature.
   - The strong scent of garlic is particularly appealing to catfish, making your bait mix a bit more tempting for them.

### Night Fishing Tips

- **Location**: Look for spots near structures or where the water is deeper. Both carp and catfish often seek such areas at night.
- **Bait Presentation**: Make sure your bait is well-secured and visible. Using a bait holder like [this one from Amazon](https://www.amazon.com/dp/B075WYPQ28?tag=tacklenet-20&linkCode=osi&th=1&psc=1) can help.

![Bait Holder](https://m.media-amazon.com/images/I/51QAY5gF6gL._SL160_.jpg)

### Weather-Specific Tip

Current conditions in Singapore show it’s **partly cloudy** with a temperature of **84.2°F** and **75% humidity**. Fish activity tends to be higher with such mild and stable conditions, as they feel comfortable to roam and feed.

### Practical Tip

- **Use a Light**: A headlamp can be handy to keep your hands free while managing your gear or bait.

In conclusion, while both carp and catfish could be on the menu, your odds might slightly favor catfish due to their nocturnal tendencies and attraction to garlic. However, fishing often surprises us, so keep an open mind and enjoy the experience! 🌟

Tight lines and may the fish be ever in your favor! 🐟

General Questions

More Questions

What are some effective fishing tips for Marina South Pier?

Where are the fish to

Where are good places to fish in Austria?

Is my size 100 Shimano Calcutta Conquest able to consistently cast 1 ounce to one and a half ounce baits?

Where is the best bass fishing spot in Hong Kong?

Is Shimano's best spinning reel for bass?

What are the best fishing lures to use in reservoirs?

What are the best swimbait hooks?