what's the difference between centerpin and fly reels?

Question

FishGPT · Accepted Answer

**Short answer:** Centerpin reels are built for river drift fishing with a fixed spool that lets line feed freely, while fly reels are built for casting fly lines and have a deliberate drag system for fighting fish. Both are cool in their own right, but they’re optimized for different jobs on the water.

**What each reel is for**
- **Centerpin reel**: designed for drift fishing in rivers (think steelhead, salmon, and big rainbows). You use a long leader and float, and you control the line primarily with your hand on the spool and the rod tip. The goal is a smooth, nearly drag-free drift, so the fish can take line off the spool naturally as the current carries the float downstream.
- **Fly reel**: designed for fly fishing with a weighted fly line. You cast with the rod and line, then manage the fight with a drag system on the reel. The reel is part of the balance of the rod-and-line setup and helps control line during the fight and when backing comes into play.

**Key differences you’ll feel on the water**
- **Spool and line management**: Centerpins use a fixed spool that spins only as the line is pulled off by the drift and the angler’s hand. Fly reels use a larger-diameter spool with backing and a floating or sinking fly line; you typically rely on the reel’s drag to control big pulls.
- **Drag behavior**: Centerpin drags are intentionally very light or nearly absent; line release is mostly governed by your thumb, rod tension, and current. Fly reels have a purpose-built drag (clicker or adjustable) to fight strong fish and absorb runs.
- **Gear and setup**: Centerpin gear means a long rod (often 9–13 ft), a fixed-spool centerpin reel, and a line setup that emphasizes drift control. Fly gear means a fly rod (often 9 ft, various weights) with a dedicated fly line and a reel sized to that line; the balance and casting rhythm are different.
- **Casting vs. drifting**: You’ll rarely cast with a centerpin; you cast with a fly rod and line. Centerpin shines when you need to present a float and baited line with a natural drift in moving water. Fly reels shine when you need precise casts and a controlled fight with a fly on the line.

**Practical tips (mid fall conditions matter)**
- If you’re wading late-season rivers with steelhead, a centerpin rig can be golden for a long, controlled drift through runs after a rain. Use a compatible centerpin setup with a strong leader and appropriate lead weight to get the float to track true in current. 
- If trout or salmon are rising in cooler water and you’re throwing dries or nymphs, a good fly reel with a solid drag helps you handle longer fights as the water cools and fish stay spooky.

**Gear to check out**
- Centerpin reel options: [Maxcatch Center Pin Floating Fishing Reel](https://www.amazon.com/dp/B09LM4ZDV1?tag=tacklenet-20&linkCode=osi&th=1&psc=1) – a solid entry point for centerpin setups.
- Fly reel options: [Piscifun Sword Fly Fishing Reel](https://www.amazon.com/dp/B072BY29G3?tag=tacklenet-20&linkCode=osi&th=1&psc=1), [Aventik Z Fly Reel](https://www.amazon.com/dp/B07JFXH4BD?tag=tacklenet-20&linkCode=osi&th=1&psc=1), [Redington Behemoth Fly Fishing Reel](https://www.amazon.com/dp/B07FYWY9DP?tag=tacklenet-20&linkCode=osi&th=1&psc=1).

If you want to see these styles in action, check: [Spring Steelheading 2024](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=58gez5UmFn4) and [Fly Fishing Slovakia - Nymph on the Revuca](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=73spjPcyHbE).

Bottom line: choose centerpin for drift-focused river fishing with a fixed spool and light drag; choose a fly reel when you’re casting flies and want reliable drag during your fish fights. Either way, you’ll be dialing in the presentation and enjoying the river—mid fall in particular can bring exciting, chilly days with big rewards. Tight lines and keep the tips up! 🐟🏞️

Rod & Reel Questions

More Questions

Is fluorocarbon or wire leader better for pike fishing?

Where is the best place to fish in Rockbridge County, VA, and what flies should I use?

What is the best time, place, rod, bait, and line to catch a marlin?

How can I improve my fishing experience at Pennypack Creek?

What are some trout fishing tips for lakes in Europe?

What is the best time to catch mackerel in San Diego?

can you give a summary of hunting kingfish from the shores of alkhobar, saudi arabia?

Question is how can I learn fishing

Is fluorocarbon or wire leader better for pike fishing?

Where is the best place to fish in Rockbridge County, VA, and what flies should I use?

What is the best time, place, rod, bait, and line to catch a marlin?

How can I improve my fishing experience at Pennypack Creek?

What are some trout fishing tips for lakes in Europe?

What is the best time to catch mackerel in San Diego?

can you give a summary of hunting kingfish from the shores of alkhobar, saudi arabia?

Question is how can I learn fishing

Rod & Reel Questions

Is the Daiwa 24 Tatula XT 642ULXS-ST a good choice for live shrimp fishing in Hong Kong targeting snapper, porgy, seabream and the occasional grouper or seabass at about a pound more or less, since they are known to be very cautious especially compared to fish in other areas.

Is the Daiwa 24 Tatula XT 642ULXS-ST a good choice for live shrimp fishing in Hong Kong targeting snapper, porgy, seabream and the occasional grouper or seabass at about a pound more or less, since they are known to be very cautious especially compared to fish in other areas.

does Major Craft Solpara SPXJ-S64ML/LJ and Daiwa BG 2500 go together well

Any recommendations for a shore jigging and baiting rod 8’-10’ for Sydney pelagics and jewfish pairing with Stella swd 8000 and PE4 with 50lb leader

Is the Daiwa 24 Tatula XT 642ULXS-ST a good choice for live shrimp fishing in Hong Kong targeting snapper, porgy, seabream and the occasional grouper or seabass at about a pound more or less, since they are known to be very cautious especially compared to fish in other areas.

Is the Daiwa 24 Tatula XT 642ULXS-ST a good choice for live shrimp fishing in Hong Kong targeting snapper, porgy, seabream and the occasional grouper or seabass at about a pound more or less, since they are known to be very cautious especially compared to fish in other areas.

does Major Craft Solpara SPXJ-S64ML/LJ and Daiwa BG 2500 go together well

Any recommendations for a shore jigging and baiting rod 8’-10’ for Sydney pelagics and jewfish pairing with Stella swd 8000 and PE4 with 50lb leader