when your lure dangling out of the water can a fish eat the whole thing

Question

FishGPT · Accepted Answer

**Short answer:** yes, it can happen. A fish can swallow a lure that’s hanging in its mouth, especially with small to medium lures or aggressive species. Whether the whole lure goes in depends on lure size, mouth size, the fish’s species, and how you’re rigging the thing.

**Why it happens**
- The fish’s mouth can be big enough to gulp down the lure if it’s small-to-midsize or a soft-bodied bait.
- Lures with exposed hooks (especially trebles) can be swallowed along with the bait, sometimes deep in the throat.
- A fast, aggressive strike from a predatory fish (think bass, pike, musky) increases the chance of full ingestion when the lure is dangling.

**What to watch for on your rig**
- If the lure is small enough relative to the fish or if the mouth closes around the lure, deep hooking is more likely.
- Treble hooks and flexible plastics are more prone to being swallowed than solid, oversized lures that resemble prey bigger than the fish’s mouth.
- The lure’s orientation when the strike happens matters: a lure dangling vertically or at a weird angle can be gulped more easily than one held firmly in line.

**Practical tips for mid fall fishing (season context)**
- Mid fall often brings cooler water and a fresh push of feeding activity. Target early mornings and late evenings around cover where lures can be nabbed aggressively.
- Use lure sizes and hooks appropriate for your target species; smaller soft plastics tend to be swallowed more often than big hard baits.
- Consider circle hooks for easier, safer releases and to reduce deep throat hooking when you’re dealing with lures that could be swallowed.
- Rig with a stout leader and keep the line taut enough to detect bites but not so tight that you yank the lure free before you feel the strike.

**Release and safety tips**
- If a fish swallows the lure, do not yank it out. Use long pliers or forceps to remove the hook if it’s shallow; otherwise cut the line and leave the lure in place if removing it would harm the fish.
- For deeply swallowed hooks, prioritize the fish’s welfare: release quickly and minimize handling.

**Gear ideas (real-world options)**
- Check out this versatile swimbait setup: [TRUSCEND Easy Catch Swimmax](https://www.amazon.com/dp/B07GP1DL4K?tag=tacklenet-20&linkCode=osi&th=1&psc=1)
- Multi-joint swimbait kits for bass, trout, and other predators: [Fishing Lures Multi Jointed Fish Kit](https://www.amazon.com/dp/B09J4CR24K?tag=tacklenet-20&linkCode=osi&th=1&psc=1)
- Soft minnow options for a natural gulp: [HALYXS Soft Minnow Lures](https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0FTTBYPFH?tag=tacklenet-20&linkCode=osi&th=1&psc=1)
- Paddle-tail swimbaits for quick action: [TRUSCEND Paddle Tail Swimbaits](https://www.amazon.com/dp/B08W2Z6VT8?tag=tacklenet-20&linkCode=osi&th=1&psc=1)
- Classic pond-targeting option: [BOOYAH Pond Magic - Sunrise Craw](https://www.amazon.com/dp/B006315TME?tag=tacklenet-20&linkCode=osi&th=1&psc=1)

**Watch a practical fishing moment**
- A lighthearted look at a tough day on the water: [My most BAD LUCK day of FISHING !!!](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8TIIAKr3XkQ)

If you’re chasing multiple species or navigating fall waters, keep experimenting with lure size and hook style, and stay patient—the bite windows can be short but brutal this time of year. Tight lines, and may your lure find the perfect perch, bass, or pike soon! 🐟

Community

General Questions

More Questions

When should I use a topwater frog lure?

Hi, I'm trying to design a new bass lure. Can you help me with that?

What is the best color to use when it’s raining?

Where are the best fishing spots in Cote D'Azur, South of France? Preferably for shore jigging

How do you catch fish at Canyon Lake, AZ in August?

What is the best crawfish color to use in Alabama in 70 to 85 degree murky water?

How many truffle worms should I get to catch a secret in Fisch?

what is the weight of DRT's 73 Remix Rod?