why did last night I have a livescope the walleye would come up and look at my bait but not eat it,I tried buckshots,jigs and live minnow but nothing worked , I was on lake Washington by mankato mn in 23 feet of water

Question

FishGPT · Accepted Answer

Sounds like a classic early-winter walleye situation on Lake Washington. They’re checking the bait but not committing, and staring down a chilly window of opportunity. Here’s a practical plan to turn those lookers into bites, with a two-rig approach you can run in the same spot.

**What’s going on**
- In early winter, walleye bounce between bottom and mid-water as temps drop and daylight shortens. They’ll come in with a look, sometimes mouth the bait, and back off if the presentation isn’t enticing enough.
- Seeing them on Livescope is a gift—use that info to tweak depth, cadence, and lure, not just the bait color.

**Two-pronged plan you can run tonight**
1) *Deadstick (no-motion) minnow just off the bottom*: set one rod with a live minnow on a light jig or a small open-water drop rig, and keep it nearly still. The goal is to offer a non-threatening target during the bite window. In ~23 ft, start the minnow 2–4 feet off the bottom. Let it sit for 60–120 seconds, then very gently lift or twitch once if nothing happens.
2) *Slow, vertical jigging with a subtle action*: on a second rod, use a small jig (1/16–1/8 oz) paired with a live minnow or a small soft bait. Drop to the same depth as the deadstick or a couple feet above it, then lift slowly 6–10 inches and pause 2–3 seconds. Repeat with short, deliberate taps. The key is slow cadence and little to no “snap”—you want to trigger a reaction bite, not scare them away.

**Lure/color tactics that work in cold water**
- Use glow or natural colors that contrast with the dim light and clear water: glow/chartreuse, or natural minnow patterns. In dim late-day conditions, glow helps.
- If you’re using jigs, pair with a small live minnow or a soft bait that mimics a finger-sized forage fish. Avoid overly aggressive jigging when the bite is tentative.
- Keep the leader light (6–12 lb fluorocarbon) and a short 12–18 inch leader if you’re using a jig-and-minnow setup. This helps the walleye breathe and bite accurately.

**How to read Livescope for bite timing**
- If a walleye approaches, watch for the moment they mouth the bait. When you see the drop and a hesitation, give a short, confident lift and hold for a beat before setting slowly.
- If they just look and back off, switch to the deadstick approach for 60–120 seconds, then re-engage with a subtle jig. Movement sometimes triggers a strike when they’re uncertain.

**Weather and timing notes (early winter)**
- Shorter days and cold fronts mean slower, more patient fishing. Early morning and late afternoon can be more productive as light diminishes and fish retreat to deeper cover.
- Calm, clear days often produce better sighting and selective feeding windows; use glow or bright accents to compensate for dim light.

**Rig options to try tonight**
- Deadstick rig: light jig or drop-rod with a live minnow, no aggressive motion, ~2–4 ft off bottom. 
- Jigging rig: 1/16–1/8 oz jig, glow color, live minnow or soft bait, steady but slow lift-pause cadence.

If you want to dial in with gear that has helped others in similar setups, consider these options (fishing-related):
- [TRUSCEND Easy Catch Swimmax](https://www.amazon.com/dp/B07GP1DL4K?tag=tacklenet-20&linkCode=osi&th=1&psc=1) — versatile swimbait action for cold-water presentations
- [TRUSCEND Fishing Lures with BKK Hooks](https://www.amazon.com/dp/B08T1FKL9Z?tag=tacklenet-20&linkCode=osi&th=1&psc=1) — effective for general walleye setups, good on 1/8 oz jigs
- [TRUSCEND Jighead Lures Paddle Tail Swimbaits](https://www.amazon.com/dp/B08X6Q799C?tag=tacklenet-20&linkCode=osi&th=1&psc=1) — good for slow-cycle jigging

Two quick rigs you can copy tonight will help you capitalize on those “lookers.” Stay patient, let the fish decide, and keep the cadence light and deliberate. You’ve got this—tight lines and steady nerves ahead! 🎣💡

Encouragement: with a bit of cadence tuning, you’ll convert those looks into bites and make those Livescope sessions pay off. I’m rooting for a solid feed next trip!

Community

🎣 Lake Washington, near Mankato, Minnesota

Walleye Questions

More Questions

How to catch bass if water is 61 degrees, cloudy, rainy, 5mph wind, and bass aren’t chasing lures?

Best bait for Springmaid pier

Guppy gave birth of 7 fry and gave a birth of only one fry after a month but it's big in size why

What lure should I use for fishing at Manly Rockwall?

What’s the best fishing spot in Istanbul?

What fly patterns are best for catching carp, tilapia, and maybe tarpon or snakehead in shallow water?

How should you place your hooks and sinkers on your line in the best way for saltwater?

Where is the best place to fish leccia in Apulia, southern Italy?