Why is my reel making a noise when retrieving and it is doing it with out line and the reel is clean and lubed

Question

FishGPT · Accepted Answer

Well my friend, that tells me this isn’t a simple “line grease gremlins” issue. A noise with no line usually points to internal wear or a binding part rather than a dirty spool. Here’s a practicalDiagnostic Playbook to chase down the culprit, plus quick fixes and solid next steps.

**First, classify the sound**
- **Grinding or scraping**: likely worn gears or bearings, or a misaligned rotor. 
- **Clicking or ticking**: could be the anti-reverse dog/bearing, or a loose screw catching each rotation. 
- **Whining or whirring**: often a dry or worn bearing or a marginally dragging drag system.

**Step-by-step troubleshooting (no line needed):**
1) Check for loose parts and binding around the bail arm and rotor. Gently wiggle the handle, bail, and rotor to feel for play or rubbing. If anything catches, tighten loose screws first; a loose side plate or bail can make serious racket. 
2) Inspect the rotor and bail system. Make sure the bail closes smoothly and the rotor doesn’t rub the frame when it spins. A misaligned bail or a sticking line roller can create odd noises even with no line. 
3) Open it up (if you’re comfortable). Look for: 
- Worn or pitted drive gears (pinion/drive gear) or a nicked tooth. 
- A dry or stuck anti-reverse bearing or mechanism. 
- Loose screws inside the body that let gears shift. 
If you see obvious wear, replacement parts are the cleanest fix. 
4) Bearings check. Spin the spool by hand (with the cover off). If the spool feels gritty or rough, the main bearings or spool bearings are dry/worn and need new bearings or a service. 
5) Lubrication check. You may still have marginal oil distribution after disassembly. Clean out old grease and apply a light, appropriate reel oil to the drive shaft, bearings, and line roller. Remember: a little goes a long way—over-lubing can attract grit and worsen noise. 
6) Drag system sanity check. Since you’re testing with no line, the drag shouldn’t drag when you wind. If you feel roughness, the drag stack or star may need inspection or replacement.
7) Reassemble and retest. Spin the rotor by hand and then wind a few turns with the handle to confirm the noise is gone or significantly reduced. If it persists, you’re likely looking at worn gears or a bearing assembly that needs replacement.

**Weather note (mid fall):** Cooler fall temps and damp air can thicken lubricants or invite condensation inside reels. If you serviced it in cool, dry conditions, give it a warm-up run in moderate temps before your next trip. This helps the oil move where it belongs and prevents new squeaks from forming once you’re outside in the chill.

**Pro tips & quick fixes**
- Use a dedicated reel oil and a light grease only where needed (drive gears, bearings, line roller). Avoid heavy grease on high-speed bearings.
- If you’re uncertain about bearings or gear wear, replace worn parts rather than “half-fix.” Rebuilds save time and money in the long run.
- Keep a small tool kit handy (tiny screwdriver set, a few q-tips for cleaning, and a dab of oil) so you can troubleshoot on-site and avoid a needless trip to the shop.

If you want a visual guide, check these quick references:
- [11 Places You SHOULD Be Greasing and Oiling Your Spinning Reel](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vkCUgxwUtqU) 
- [How to oil and grease a spinning reel #fishing #fishingtips #fishingreels](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WMXln5qG34A) 
- [TACKLE HACK | How To Fix A Noisy Reel.](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kWC5HmOUFtE) 
- [Clean, Oil, & Grease Your Spinning Reel Made EASY!](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pX6Xz-6bsN0)

If you’d like, tell me your reel model and the exact sound (grind, click, hum) and I’ll tailor a targeted parts list and steps. You’ve got this—get that reel singing again and start casting with confidence! 🎣

Rod & Reel Questions

More Questions

What should I throw today at Windber Country Club in Johnstown, PA?

How to start fishing in AZ?

How can I fish for seabass in Guardamar del Segura?

How to catch smallmouth bass?

What size offset worm hook is best for white bass?

What is the best size and color for a Dolly Llama fly when targeting Kenai Dolly Varden in August?

Is it allowed to fish from shore at Riserva Naturale di Punta Bianca?

What are the best places to catch stripers in the California Delta?